Shannon County Route 19: Current River Bridge Alternatives

Bridge G0804 carries Route 19 over the Current River north of Round Spring. The bridge is 602 feet long carrying an 18-foot roadway. The bridge has been reduced to a single lane and has a posted load limit. The current bridge condition ratings from the last available official inspection in October 2019 indicate the bridge is in fair condition. 

The following alternatives were explored.

C-1A

View Aerial

Description:

  • New bridge on existing alignment.
  • A grated two-lane temporary bridge will be built prior to construction of the new bridge and will be removed after the new bridge is constructed.
  • Existing pedestrian bridge to be removed prior to temporary bridge construction.
  • Pedestrians will be accommodated on the new bridge.

Advantages

  • Matches location of existing bridge.
  • Less permanent roadway work.
  • Uses a two-lane temporary bridge during construction.

Disadvantages

  • Additional cost for temporary bridge.
  • Utilities on the existing pedestrian bridge must be relocated.
  • Longer construction period.
  • Extensive formwork in the channel.

C-1B

View Aerial

Description:

  • New bridge on existing alignment.
  • A grated two-lane temporary bridge will be built prior to construction of the new bridge and will be removed after the new bridge is constructed.
  • Existing pedestrian bridge retained but not accessible during new bridge construction.

Advantages

  • Matches location of existing bridge.
  • Less permanent roadway work.
  • Uses a two-lane temporary bridge during construction.
  • Utilities remain on existing pedestrian bridge.

Disadvantages

  • Additional cost for temporary bridge.
  • Longer construction period.
  • Extensive formwork in the channel.

C-2A

View Aerial

Description:

  • New bridge on existing alignment.
  • A grated one-lane temporary bridge will be built prior to construction of the new bridge and will be removed after the new bridge is constructed.
  • Existing pedestrian bridge to be removed prior to temporary bridge construction.
  • Pedestrians will be accommodated on the new bridge.

Advantages

  • Matches location of existing bridge.
  • Less permanent roadway work.

Disadvantages

  • Utilities on the existing pedestrian bridge must be relocated.
  • Uses a one-lane temporary bridge during construction.
  • Additional cost for temporary bridge.
  • Longer construction period.
  • Extensive formwork in the channel.

C-2B

View Aerial

Description:

  • New bridge on existing alignment.
  • A grated one-lane temporary bridge will be built prior to construction of the new bridge and will be removed after the new bridge is constructed.
  • Existing pedestrian bridge retained but not accessible during new bridge construction.

Advantages

  • Matches location of existing bridge.
  • Less permanent roadway work.
  • Utilities remain on existing pedestrian bridge.

Disadvantages

  • Uses a one-lane temporary bridge during construction.
  • Additional cost for temporary bridge.
  • Longer construction period.
  • Extensive formwork in the channel.

C-3A

View Aerial

Description:

  • New bridge downstream (east) of existing bridge.
  • No temporary bridge required.
  • Existing pedestrian bridge to be removed prior to new bridge construction.
  • Pedestrians will be accommodated on the new bridge.

Advantages

  • No temporary bridge required; cost savings.
  • Shorter construction period.

Disadvantages

  • Utilities on the existing pedestrian bridge must be relocated.
  • More permanent roadway work.
  • Uses the existing one-lane bridge during construction.

C-3B

View Aerial

Description:

  • New bridge downstream (east) of existing bridge.
  • No temporary bridge required.
  • Existing pedestrian bridge retained but not accessible during new bridge construction.

Advantages

  • No temporary bridge required; cost savings.
  • Shorter construction period.
  • Utilities remain on existing pedestrian bridge.

Disadvantages

  • More permanent roadway work.
  • Uses the existing one-lane bridge during construction.

C-4

View Aerial

Description:

  • Multiple phase rehabilitation of the existing bridge.
  • No temporary bridge.
  • Existing pedestrian bridge retained and accessible during non-construction hours.   

Advantages

  • Matches location of the existing bridge.
  • No temporary bridge required; cost savings.
  • Less permanent roadway work.
  • Utilities remain on the existing pedestrian bridge.

Disadvantages

  • Uses the existing one-lane bridge during construction.
  • Longer construction period.
  • Remediated concrete of the existing bridge is buried in the structure, possibly requiring further rehabilitation in the future.
  • Shorter life expectancy compared to a new bridge.

C-5A

View Aerial

Description:

  • Single-phase rehabilitation of the existing bridge.
  • A grated two-lane temporary bridge will be built and will be removed after the rehabilitation of the existing bridge is complete.
  • Existing pedestrian bridge to be removed prior to temporary bridge construction.
  • Pedestrians will be accommodated on the rehabilitated bridge.

Advantages

  • Matches location of existing bridge.
  • Less permanent roadway work.
  • Uses a two-lane temporary bridge during construction.

Disadvantages

  • Additional cost for temporary bridge.
  • Remediated concrete of the existing bridge is buried in the structure, possibly requiring further rehabilitation in the future.
  • Shorter life expectancy compared to a new bridge.
  • Utilities on the existing pedestrian bridge must be relocated.
  • Extensive formwork in the channel.

C-5B

View Aerial

Description:

  • Single-phase rehabilitation of the existing bridge.
  • A grated two-lane temporary bridge will be built and will be removed after the rehabilitation of the existing bridge is complete.
  • Existing pedestrian bridge retained but not accessible during bridge rehabilitation.

Advantages

  • Matches location of existing bridge.
  • Less permanent roadway work.
  • Uses a two-lane temporary bridge during construction.
  • Utilities remain on existing pedestrian bridge.

Disadvantages

  • Additional cost for temporary bridge.
  • Remediated concrete of the existing bridge is buried in the structure, possibly requiring further rehabilitation in the future.
  • Shorter life expectancy compared to a new bridge.
  • Extensive formwork in the channel.

No-Build Alternative

Cost: Variable depending on inspection results

Description:

  • This alternative leaves the bridge in place. Routine maintenance of the bridge would continue, but no major rehabilitation would be done. Without a major rehabilitation or replacement project, the bridge would likely be closed in the next 10 years.
  • This alternative is required to be carried forward in the environmental assessment process as a baseline for comparison purposes.

Advantages

  • Little to no environmental concerns

Disadvantages

  • High maintenance costs
  • Doesn't meet current design standards
  • The deck, substructure, and superstructure wouldn't be improved
  • Shorter life span